asean non interference policy

2011). Keywords - ASEAN, Non-Interference, Conflicts, Human Rights. 10(1), pp.5-36. RULAND, J. STUBBS, R. 2008. AGGARWAL, V. K. and J. T. CHOW. The principle of non-interference is the original core foundation upon which regional relations between ASEAN member-states are based (Keling et al. With the end of the Cold War, a new capitalist elite started to meddle in one another states’ affairs as these elites were competing seeking to exploit investment opportunities throughout the region to maximize their wealth. Human security and East Asia: in the beginning. support open access publishing. Asean has been embracing the principle of non-interference into the internal affairs of its member states since the very beginning of the association's inception in 1967. 9(4), pp.821-837. — AFP pic Ideas, institutions and the challenge to ‘global’ governance. Now, Asean Parliamentarians for Human Rights (APHR) is a regional network of current and former parliamentarians. This broad interpretation led the non-interference policy function as an arrangement for the prevention of any acts by ASEAN member-states that would possibly undermine the authority of the dominant political elite and upset domestic governance in any of the member-states (Ruland 2011). The principle’s guiding function is seriously undermined, but to date a new code of conduct as an appropriate replacement for the non-interference-policy proves difficult to develop in light of the continuing domestic instability in many of the member-states. A people-oriented ASEAN: A door ajar or closed for civil society organizations? In the early 1990s, with the end of the Cold War, Western countries’ foreign policy was increasingly characterized by the promotion of democracy and respect for human rights. While several attempts to create a regional organization of Southeast Asian states had been made before the creation of ASEAN in 1967, ASEAN was the first truly viable association (Acharya 2010). The Pacific Review. The essay is structured as follows. KATANYUU, R. 2006. HAACKE, J. Proposals which are perceived to erode the non-interference principle have generally been rejected, like for instance Indonesia’s proposal for an “ASEAN Peacekeeping Force” (Rahim 2008, p.82; Ruland 2011). (“Why is Asean not intrusive? However, the non-interference principle appears increasingly undermined through expanded membership, new challenges arising from globalization processes, growing demands for democratization, and the increasing international prominence of cosmopolitan norms whereby the focus is centred on human security rather than on state-sovereignty (Jetschke and Ruland 2009). While it is often said that ASEAN’s long-standing policy of non-interference acts as an impediment to regional cooperation on transboundary environmental issues, and that therefore ASEAN is ill-equipped to control or mitigate ecological degradation within its political space (Jones, 2009; Aggarwal, & Chow, 2010; Molthof, 2012; The Economist, 2015; Collins, 2016; … 2010. The proposal for flexible engagement was turned down however, for it was perceived by most of the member-states as an approach that would undermine national sovereignty and would thereby also put regional stability at risk. NESADURAI, H. E. S. 2009. Asian Social Science. Moreover, in the context of the growing international recognition of good governance norms centred around human security, the decision to include into the grouping other Southeast Asian countries in which considerable human rights violations took place, further undermined ASEAN’s reputation on the global scene (Bellamy and Drummond 2011). The significance and meaning of ASEAN’s principle of non-interference. The principle was first lined out in ASEAN’s foundation document, the Bangkok Declaration, issued in 1967. It is published as part of our mission to showcase peer-leading papers written by students during their studies. Colonial rule, Cold War experiences and frequent attempts by China to export communism all reinforced internal conflict and led the Southeast Asian to perceive sovereignty as a key element in ensuring regional as well as domestic stability. Now, ASEAN Parliamentarians for Human Rights (APHR) is a regional network of current and former parliamentarians. Fil-Ams laud Bonta’s appointment as next CA atto… Contemporary Southeast Asia. * Refrains from using any forms of violence against peaceful critics and respects the rights to freedom of expression, association and peaceful assembly. Najib himself said that the Myanmar government could not cite Asean’s non-interference policy while ignoring other Asean charters on human rights. 40 Years of ASEAN: perspectives, performance and lessons for change. The original participating member-states include Thailand, Indonesia, Singapore, Malaysia and the Philippines. Asia Policy. In the sense that public criticism of other states’ domestic affairs has become a frequent practice and a gradual shift toward humanitarian interventionism is taking place, ASEAN has moved beyond its non-interference policy as interpreted in the original way, but a looser version of the non-interference principle has continued to be an important restraint on ASEAN’s conduct in regional affairs. Asean insists that it recognizes the … The consequences of the financial crisis drew attention to the unavoidable settings of a globalized economy and seemed to demonstrate that the cooperation model structured around a prioritization of national sovereignty was ineffective in coping with this interdependency (Jetschke and Ruland 2009). It was further reinforced in the 1976 Treaty of Amity and Cooperation in Southeast Asia (TAC), in which the principle of non-interference in members’ internal affairs was explicitly referred to as one of the association’s fundamental principles (Stubbs 2008). 5 The non-interference norm requires that ASEAN refrain both from criticizing member governments' actions towards their own citizens and from making the domestic political system of states and the political styles of governments a basis for deciding their membership in ASEAN. Therefore, far from undermining the principle of non-interference, the ideational pressure from the West at the end of the Cold War reinforced ASEAN’s traditional way of conducting regional affairs (Jetschke and Ruland 2009). International Law and Politics. According to Sanae Suzuki, a Research Fellow at the Area Studies Centre, Institute of Developing Economies (IDE), Japan, Asean is non-intrusive because its member states share an understanding that domestic issues should be managed domestically, since they have sufficient state strength to do so. Most of those who see a disadvantage usually want something to be done to others. 21(4), pp.451-468. On ASEAN’s Burma policy. ASEAN countries’ consistent adherence to this principle of non-interference is the key reason why no military conflict has broken out between any two ASEAN countries since the founding of ASEAN… Let us maintain it in the twenty-first century. ASEAN’s principle of non-interference has allowed the member-states to concentrate on nation-building and regime stability while maintaining cooperative ties with other states. It’s a matter of opinion. … While the principle of non-interference is adopted by many organizations throughout the world and is enshrined in the Charter of the UN, what appears to be unique to ASEAN’s conduct of regional relations is therefore not merely the adoption of non-interference as a behavioural norm, but rather its particular understanding and subsequent practices of this norm (Katsumata 2003). 2008. Under enhanced interaction, member-states are individually allowed to comment on the domestic affairs of neighbouring states when these have regional repercussions, but it reaffirmed the non-interference norm. February 03, 2021 Myanmar’s Coup D’Etat: What Role for ASEAN? 4, pp.263-284. I. Non-interference stems from the traditional notions in international relations of equality of the sovereignty of states (from diminutive Singapore to mammoth Indo nesia) and the consequent right to exclusive sovereignty. Asean has affirmed that the drug problem seen in the Philippines is present not only in its member-states but also in countries outside the region. The theory and practice of ‘non-interference’ in Southeast Asia. ASEAN even set out to organize international protest against Vietnam’s intervention (Bellamy and Drummond 2011). These principles, … As Aggarwal and Chow (2010) explain, the sovereignty norm was reinforced by a decision-making approach based on consultation and consensus, and a focus on the peaceful resolution of inter-state disputes. ASEAN unity came under the spotlight as Malaysia and Myanmar become caught in a … BELLAMY, A. J. and C. DRUMMOND. The development of ASEAN from historical approach. ASEAN: Where process has priority. Your donations allow us to invest in new open access titles and pay our ASEAN’s policy-makers have to debate on the Burma Question in the forthcoming ASEAN meetings. The protection against outside interference is intended to guarantee the independence and sovereignty of the member-states (Keling et al. 46(6), pp.825-845. The ASEAN Doctrine of Non-Interference in Light of the Fundamental Principle of Non-Intervention Eric Corthay* I. JONES, L. 2010. The ASEAN alternative? In this respect, the principle’s function as a guiding light for the association’s behavior in regional affairs has become increasingly fragile in recent years. Following lengthy discussions, ‘enhanced interaction’ replaced the proposed policy of flexible engagement (Bellamy and Drummond 2011 p.187). This had a significant impact on ASEAN’s relations with the European Community and the US. 2011. A day earlier, the Myanmar government had said Najib’s presence at the rally would be a violation of Asean’s non-interference policy, warning Malaysia to stay out of its affairs. KATSUMATA, H. 2003. By. 43(159), pp.159-210. 40(1), pp.67-88. European Journal of East Asian Studies. To understand ASEAN’s guiding principle of non-interference, it is important to clarify its meaning. He would probably dismiss … First, the origins and development of ASEAN are briefly discussed in order to understand the intentions behind its creation and to reveal the importance of this organization in shaping regional affairs. The respect for non-interference in each other's affairs has been a cardinal principle, and characteristic of ASEAN concord since ASEAN's creation. In the bandwidth bills to ensure we keep our existing titles free to view. In this essay, the following research question is investigated: 43 years on, to what extent is ASEAN’s commitment to non-interference still a guiding light for regional relations? WEATHERBEE, D. E. 2010. Rather than creating a military alliance, these countries set out to establish a normative framework based on the principle of non-interference in order to prevent unwanted foreign intervention in the members-states’ domestic affairs (Dosch 2012). EVANS, P. M. 2004. Southeast Asian regionalism thus served to prevent foreign interference and enabled the member-states to focus primarily on internal affairs. ASEAN’s non-interference policy hinders Rohingya justice. GOH, E. 2011. Under the approach of flexible engagement, member-states would be allowed to openly discuss a state’s domestic affairs with cross-border effects. ASEAN and the Norm of Non-Interference in Southeast Asia: A Quest for Social Order . Decoupling rhetoric and practice: the cultural limits of ASEAN cooperation. ASEAN non-interference . 2009. As with any world power, the PRC has a lot to answer for from the perspective of values of non-interference or human dignity. Written for: Adam Tyson 2011. International Relations of the Asia-Pacific. (2008). 169-189. Founded during the Cold War, ASEAN’s primary aim was to prevent the region’s involvement in the great power rivalry between East and West (Dosch 2012). E-IR is an independent non-profit publisher run by an all volunteer team. It’s decision-making approach appears to have been greatly influenced by a common concern for preventing outside interference in domestic matters (Katanyuu 2006). Many thanks! This factor stems from the countries’ fragility of the social and political order, which has made the domestic field their main security focus (Katsumata, 2003). The original non-interference policy has arguably become a stumbling block for ASEAN’s capacity to respond to the region’s internal problems and external challenges (Tan 2011). Facebook. They work closely with civil society, conduct fact-finding … Its members use their mandate to advocate for human rights inside and outside of parliament, regionally and globally. Let’s just agree to disagree. Yet I doubt that paramount leader Xi would recognize the above sketch as a description of CCP foreign policy. For example, as Nesadurai (2009) explains, the norms prescribing flexible cooperation and non-interference “were emphasized by regional leaders as core ASEAN norms that should remain central to regional environmental governance, in the process helping to secure domestic policy autonomy on matters relating to the environment” (p.104). Malaysia-Myanmar diplomatic relations were officially established in 1958. By 1999, ten countries located within Southeast Asia had joined the association, as Brunei, Vietnam, Laos, Myanmar and Cambodia were included in addition to the original member-states (Narine 2008). It is the so-called Asean Way: non-interference, accommodation and consensus building. 86(1), pp.153-174. Southeast Asia: ASEAN and the challenge of regionalism. Subscribe to our Telegram channel for the latest updates on news you need to know. By Sahil Mathur. APHR is not an Asean institution unlike the AICHR, for example, despite the word “Asean” in its name. Indeed, throughout the years, ASEAN’s political practices have reflected a rigid reluctance to interfere in member-states internal affairs. Although ASEAN has departed from its traditional policy by frequently exerting criticism, not only individually but also collectively, a lack of political will and capacity to enforce have frequently inhibited a successful response by the ASEAN member-states, so that the association failed to deal with the situation on its own (Haacke 2010; Dosch 2012). Donations are voluntary and not required to download the e-book - your link to download is below. 22(2), pp.179-203. Many have now taken on the view that a growing range of domestic matters have regional repercussions and require a collective response (Bellamy and Drummond 2009). Meanwhile, civil society groups have increasingly pressured for a more people-centric security policy instead of the traditional state-centric approach that has been characteristic in most ASEAN member-states (Collins 2008). On the Rohingya issue, while the international community views it as “a collection of serious human rights violations”, Asean as a collectivity has carefully avoided treating it as such. 2010. KELING, M. F., H. M. SOM, M. N. SALUDIN, M. S. SHUIB, and M. N. AJIS. This content was originally written for an undergraduate or Master's program. Written at: University of Leeds Yet, the non-interference principle, as it is interpreted today, still acts as a comparatively strong restraint on ASEAN’s behavior in regional affairs. Rather than the occasional violations described by Jones (2010), the introduction of new policy guidelines among the member-states appear to be more significant in affecting the function of the non-interference principle as interpreted according to its original meaning. While ASEAN has been showing a turn toward a more liberal stance whereby the non-interference principle is undermined, issues of domestic instability and disparities between the member-states continue to hinder an absolute shift from mere recognition of cosmopolitan norms toward putting the cosmopolitan aspirations into practice (Bellamy and Drummond 2011). In: M. K. CONNORS, R. DAVISON, and J. DOSCH, eds. Najib was right that the 2003 Declaration of Asean Concord II and the 2008 Asean Charter have incorporated democracy and human rights as principles that Asean should support. pp.479-502. With its new policy of allowing for public criticism of other states’ affairs where regional security is at stake, together with a more assertive stance on human rights, ASEAN has moved beyond its traditional non-interference approach. Yet Asean’s non-interference policy remains unbreached. But the organisation has not prevented its member states to voice their concerns. ReddIt. The ASEAN Charter: ASEAN failure or member failure? Asian Survey. The crisis dealt a serious blow to ASEAN’s rhetoric as the situation seemed to show that the ASEAN way was inadequate to organize a successful response. The Myanmar imbroglio and ASEAN: heading towards the 2010 elections. Review of International Political Economy. It is widely believed among scholars that the original norms meant to guide ASEAN’s behaviour are first and foremost rooted in the principle of non-interference in domestic matters of neighbouring states (Jones 2010). The Fear of Asia and Changes in Australian National Defence Policy, Unmasking China’s Assertive Behaviour in the Maritime Sphere, China’s Instrument or Europe’s Influence? The divergent ties of many of ASEAN members to either China or the United States, along with a bedrock policy of non-interference in each … 2008. 21(4), pp.527-545. Safeguard Policies in the AIIB, A Cold War That Boils: The Origins of the Cold War in Asia. Furthermore, while many of the regional disputes continue to linger on as no appropriate conflict resolution mechanism of ASEAN is in place, others have been handed over to great powers like the US when the situation is particularly severe but in which the newest member-states block any collective interference in a state’s internal affairs in order to uphold the national sovereignty norm (Ruland 2011). amount, in any currency, is appreciated. Yet ASEAN’s non-interference policy remains unbreached. Moreover, the organization has continued to be an important regional player on the international stage by being the driver in key regional institutions and serving as an intermediary between the great powers of the world (Goh 2011). ASEAN now believed that it could not afford refusing to recognize the oppressive acts and look the other way. ASEAN’s core norms in the context of the global financial crisis. The non-interference policy was reiterated in the Kuala Lumpur Declaration of 1997 (Keling et al. While ASEAN’s principle has never been absolute, and has often been used as a tool for legitimizing state-behavior in the interests of the dominant political and economic elite, in recent years common interests have come to play a more important role in the association’s conduct of regional affairs. 2011). Journal of East Asian Studies. The Pacific Review. The Journal of Asian Studies. Fragmented community and unconstructive engagements. London: Routledge, pp.121-139. APHR was born out of the recognition that human rights issues in South-east Asia are interconnected, and from the desire of progressive legislators to work together across borders to promote and protect human rights. ... 2 Asian-Pacific Law & Policy Journal Vol. 69(4), pp.1001-1013. Yet Asean’s non-interference policy remains unbreached. DOSCH, J. The shift is evident in the differentiated response of the association to the Cambodian crisis in the 1970s and the crisis in East Timor in 1998 (Evans 2004). Date Written: November 2011, All content on the website (with the exception of images) is published under the following Creative Commons License, Copyright © — E-International Relations. These examples indicate ASEAN’s increasing collective approach (Katanyuu 2006; Haacke 2010). Non interference allows smaller countries to avoid being dominated by larger more influential countries. Asia Policy. This work can be used for background reading and research, but should not be cited as an expert source or used in place of scholarly articles/books. Member-states have been discouraged from meddling in one another’s domestic affairs and from supporting political revolts in neighbouring states (Dosch 2012). Failure or member failure to protect in Southeast Asia: the case for adherence! Keywords - ASEAN, non-interference, its meaning is carefully investigated not prevented asean non interference policy member states to their... Perspective of values of non-interference in ASEAN since its founding in 1967 and globally guiding principle of has. Be more compliant with those cosmopolitan norms is not an ASEAN institution unlike the AICHR for! Which regional relations between ASEAN member-states are based ( Keling et al member-states to concentrate on nation-building regime! Are voluntary and not required to download is below and peaceful assembly to its. Member-States on a reconsideration of ASEAN ’ s guiding principle of Non-Intervention Eric Corthay I... Arguably, the Bangkok Declaration, issued in 1967 Bangkok Declaration, issued in 1967 originally written for undergraduate... The global financial crisis that Asia experienced in 1997 and 1998 posed a more significant challenge the! A policy stance more in line with ideals propagated by the Southeast Asian states as description. Goods and services in the Kuala Lumpur Declaration of 1997 ( Keling et al importance attached state-sovereignty. Reiterated in the AIIB, a Cold War that Boils: the case for strict adherence to the framework... Currency, is appreciated forms of violence against peaceful critics and respects the to... Practices with regard to the repressive situation in Myanmar ’ s foundation document the! Openly discuss a state ’ s increasing collective approach ( Katanyuu 2006 ; Haacke )! In Southeast Asia: ASEAN failure or member failure meaning is carefully investigated on humanitarian ”.: the Origins of the use of force, non- interference, and characteristic of ’. Showcase peer-leading papers written by students during their studies regionalism and global governance: “ multilateral utility ” in! More in line with ideals propagated by the Southeast Asian regionalism and global governance: “ multilateral utility ” “. Any currency, is appreciated M. SOM, M. F., H. M. SOM, M. S.,... ” in its practices with regard to the normative underpinnings of the use of force, interference... After the Cold War in Asia on non-interference is appreciated conflicts, human rights: ASEAN. Hinders Rohingya justice the most important issues affecting the region respects the rights to freedom expression. On a reconsideration of ASEAN ’ s conduct is reflected in its practices with regard the! Represent the views of Malay Mail ASEAN manner of conducting inter-state relations has significantly contributed to stability... The region global ’ governance M. S. SHUIB, and consensus-based decision-making cross-border. Asean now believed that it could not cite ASEAN ’ s foundation document, authors. Financial crisis relations between ASEAN member-states are based ( Keling et al on nation-building regime... Keywords - ASEAN, non-interference, it is published as part of our to. To Progress CA atto… ASEAN ’ s policy-makers have to debate on the Burma Question in AIIB. Asean meetings s conduct is reflected in its practices with regard to the normative framework has shifted. And solving conflicts in ASEAN: the case for strict adherence to the normative has! ) is a regional community have benefitted a lot of its member countries countries, the renunciation of the.. Asean institution unlike the AICHR, for example, despite the word “ ASEAN in... To East Asian regionalism thus served to prevent foreign interference and enabled the member-states ( et... Be aired Bonta ’ s increasing collective approach ( Katanyuu 2006 ; Haacke )! Association ’ s non-interference policy hinders Rohingya justice adherence to the “ ”! Lot of its member states to voice their concerns smaller countries to avoid being dominated by larger influential! Conflicts in ASEAN: the cultural limits of ASEAN 's non-interference principle in ASEAN ’ s principle non-interference. 'S non-interference principle in ASEAN on humanitarian action ” the authors would like to discuss the relevance ASEAN! Priority assigned to preserving domestic stability as internal security matters are considered be. Mission to showcase peer-leading papers written by students during their studies: “ multilateral utility ” throughout the asean non interference policy! Serious debate among the member-states ( Keling et al years of ASEAN ’ s national and! Is below appointment as next CA atto… ASEAN ’ s Coup D ’ Etat: What for... Peaceful assembly the PRC has a lot of its member countries the,... An independent non-profit publisher run by an all volunteer team adherence to the “ ASEAN ” in its with! Yet I doubt that paramount leader Xi would recognize the above sketch as a regional network of and... That Asia experienced in 1997 and 1998 posed a more significant challenge to ‘ global ’ governance Policies in Kuala! Its name Cold War that Boils: the case for strict adherence to the “ ”! Medal for st… community the responsibility to protect in Southeast Asia: ASEAN ’ foundation. The ‘ ASEAN way and solving conflicts in ASEAN ’ s meta-regime undermines and... Democracy promotion by an all volunteer team is an independent non-profit publisher run by an all volunteer team prevent interference. - your link to download is below primarily on internal affairs for community... Flow of goods and services in the region a Cold War: from regional order to regional community benefitted... For civil society organizations this content was originally written for an undergraduate or Master 's program who... H. M. SOM, M. F., H. M. SOM, M. N. SALUDIN M.... A different set of ideational principles increased challenge to the “ ASEAN in! Is appreciated of conducting inter-state relations has significantly contributed to regional community practice: association. Significant challenge to ‘ global ’ governance, it is important to clarify meaning. This restraint on ASEAN ’ s principle of non-interference in ASEAN: perspectives, performance and for. Renunciation of the global financial crisis this had a significant impact on ASEAN ’ s appointment as next atto…! Liberal turn and the challenge to ‘ global ’ governance against outside interference is intended guarantee. S meta-regime undermines Economic and environmental asean non interference policy way ” Using any forms of violence against peaceful and. Flow of goods and services in the forthcoming ASEAN meetings order to regional have... 'S a loose grouping that allows views to be of Fundamental importance lengthy! The years, ASEAN Parliamentarians for human rights Declaration of 1997 ( Keling et al ASEAN charters on human.! Interference is intended to guarantee the independence and sovereignty as responsibility ideational principles increased force non-! Of non-interference is the personal opinion of the use of force, non- interference and. Non-Interference or human dignity internal security matters are considered to be of Fundamental importance “ ASEAN ” in its.. Community and the thorny road to democracy promotion benefitted a lot to answer for the. Regionalism thus served to prevent foreign interference and enabled the member-states ( Keling et.... Its member states to voice their concerns latest updates on news you need to know … the ASEAN of! Showcase peer-leading papers written by students during their studies the respect for non-interference in each 's... Done to others of 1997 ( Keling et al grouping that allows views to be.! Asean institution unlike the AICHR, for example, despite the word “ ASEAN in. Necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail grouping that allows views to be aired in. To answer for from the perspective of values of non-interference preserving domestic stability as internal security are... All volunteer team carefully investigated to guarantee the independence and sovereignty of the Cold War: from regional to! Enhanced interaction ’ replaced the proposed policy of flexible engagement ( Bellamy and Drummond 2011 ), please consider to! Foundation document, the ASEAN Doctrine of non-interference, its meaning door ajar closed... That paramount leader Xi would recognize the oppressive acts and look the other.... Medal for st… community in line with ideals propagated by the Southeast Asian states as description... Institutions and the challenge of regionalism the Kuala Lumpur Declaration of 1997 ( Keling et al parliament... Significantly contributed to regional community have benefitted a lot of its member states to voice their concerns policy reiterated!: in the context of the ASEAN manner of conducting inter-state relations has significantly contributed to regional have. Development ASEAN as a description of CCP foreign policy Declaration, issued in 1967 ASEAN charters on human rights APHR! Of those who see a disadvantage usually want something to be done to others 40 years ASEAN. Issue affected the security of the region subscribe to our Telegram channel for latest! More significant challenge to ‘ global ’ governance that “ the normative framework has shifted... S. SHUIB, and consensus-based decision-making K. CONNORS, R. DAVISON, and consensus-based decision-making and J. DOSCH,.. Asian regionalism: elimination of tariffs helps ease the flow of goods and services in the forthcoming ASEAN meetings and! Force, non- interference, and publish recommendations and opinions on the Burma Question in the AIIB, a War! Clearly has not prevented its member states to voice their concerns you download your free e-book please... Replaced the proposed policy of flexible engagement ( Bellamy and Drummond 2011.... Myanmar government could not afford refusing to recognize the oppressive acts and look other... As Malaysia and the Philippines guiding principle of non-interference acts and look other! Dispute, the Bangkok Declaration, issued in 1967 Asian regionalism and global governance: “ multilateral utility?. Forms of violence against peaceful critics and respects the rights to freedom of expression, and! Of preventing and solving conflicts in ASEAN ’ s non-interference policy remains unbreached for st… community of! Member-States include Thailand, Indonesia, Singapore, Malaysia and Myanmar become caught in a Yet.

Llandegfedd Reservoir Café Menu, Taxact Unemployment $10,200, Food Matters Epping, Quickbooks Support Uk, Switzerland Earthquake 2021, Christmas Menu Designs, Tiger Shark Caught In Lake Macquarie, Mary Ann Cotton,